Skip to content
BorderStrife New campaign

Player’s manual Chapter 04 of 08

Read as Markdown

Battles and forecasts

Understand attack odds, simultaneous resolution, casualties, retreats and forecast assumptions.

Contents and chapters

Combat, crossings and forecasts

Victory depends on effective strength, not troop counts alone. Apply supply to each attacking army, account for its crossing, then combine friendly attacks. Defenders receive terrain and supply modifiers.

Two armies, one target. Both armies belong to you and attack the same region this turn. Their effective strengths combine; each approach keeps its own crossing modifier.
Combat, crossings and forecasts
ApproachCrossing defense multiplier
Road×1
River crossing×1.2
Mountain pass×1.15
Sea landing×1.25
Odds
Win probability = attack² ÷ (attack² + defense²), using effective strengths. A 2:1 effective advantage gives 80% odds; 3:1 gives 90%. Neither guarantees victory.
Worked example
A supplied army of 100 crossing a river contributes 100 ÷ 1.2 ≈ 83.3 effective attack. Fifty defenders in forest have 50 × 1.5 = 75 effective defense. The attacker has about 55% odds, despite a 2:1 advantage in troops.
Mixed approaches
When several armies attack through different crossings, each army’s contribution is adjusted separately. Use the combined forecast rather than applying one crossing multiplier to every army.
Forecast limits
Forecasts assume defenders stay put and account for known recruitment. Enemy departures, reinforcements and competing attacks can change the result.
Casualties and retreat
Winning can still cost troops. Defeated survivors retreat after all battles if a friendly destination remains; without refuge, they are lost.

In the field. Bring a margin of strength, coordinate neighboring armies and leave a route back. Use the battle report to inspect why the result differed from your plan.

What happens when you end a turn

  1. Recruitment. Every region adds its recruits. Supply is checked from the position before movement. New recruits join the army that will move.
  2. Movement. All planned armies depart together. Friendly arrivals merge. Incoming troops do not travel a second hop on that turn.
  3. Combat. Your armies attacking the same region combine. Different commanders remain independent; competing attacks on one target resolve in a randomized order.
  4. Retreats and objectives. Defeated survivors seek friendly refuge after all battles. Then objectives and eliminations are checked, the turn advances and the resolved position is saved.

In the field. An army leaving a region can leave it empty even while that commander attacks elsewhere. Your forecast cannot know those rival orders.

Inside a battle

A battle uses effective strength to decide the winner, then calculates casualties. The larger army is favored, not certain to win.

  1. Calculate the attack. For each source: troops × supply factor ÷ crossing multiplier. Add contributions from armies belonging to the same commander and attacking the same target.
  2. Calculate the defense. Defending troops × terrain multiplier × supply factor. The troops present when that battle begins defend the region.
  3. Draw the outcome. Attack² ÷ (attack² + defense²) gives the attacker’s win probability. A random draw below that probability wins. A positive army captures an empty region without a contest.
  4. Apply losses. Use the relative effective strengths and a further random draw to calculate casualties. The surviving winner holds the region; defeated survivors await retreat.
  5. Find refuge. Retreats resolve after all battles. A surviving defeated force needs a friendly destination; without one, its survivors are lost.
Attacker wins
Hardness is effective defense ÷ effective attack, capped at 1. Attacker losses are rounded down from attacking troops × hardness × a random factor from 0.25 to 0.55. At least one attacker survives. Defeated defenders retain a rounded-down 35–60% of their troops before retreat.
Defender wins
Defeated attackers retain a rounded-down 35–60% before retreat. Defender losses are rounded down from defending troops × min(effective attack ÷ effective defense, 1) × a random factor from 0.20 to 0.50. The remaining defender count cannot fall below zero.
Small-strength safeguard
For casualty ratios, a denominator below 1 is treated as 1. This affects casualty arithmetic, not the strength-squared win probability.
Separate rivals
Armies from different commanders never combine into one attack. Competing attacks on a target resolve in randomized order. A later attack meets the surviving force left by earlier battles.
Probability versus result
A 2:1 effective advantage wins 80% of battles; a 3:1 advantage wins 90%. One defeat does not contradict either forecast. Winning and preserving troops are different questions.

In the field. Judge an attack by its odds, likely exposure and route back. An expensive victory can leave the captured region vulnerable to the next army.

What forecasts can tell you

Included
Current troop counts, known recruitment, terrain, supply and the approach used by your planned attack. Combined friendly attacks contribute separately through their own crossings.
Assumed
The defending army remains at its region. A forecast is calculated from the known position, before every commander’s orders resolve.
Uncertain
Enemy departures, incoming reinforcements, competing attacks and the battle’s random draw. An earlier battle can change both the owner and army you encounter.
Border threats
Threat indicators estimate danger from adjacent hostile forces. Independent enemy factions are considered separately; they are not one combined attacking army.
After the turn
Read the battle report’s effective strengths and modifiers. Compare the troops that actually fought with the position you forecast. Use replay to inspect the wider sequence where history is available.

In the field. Use a forecast to compare plans. Use the resolved report to explain the outcome.